EASY Grilled Caprese Sandwich (10 minutes!) - I Heart Naptime (2024)

Grilled caprese sandwich stuffed with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil pesto! Takes 10 minutes or less and requires just 5 simple ingredients!

This post may contain affiliate links. Read disclosure policy.

Crispy Grilled Summer Sandwich

One of my all-time favorite sandwiches is a grilled caprese sandwich. I’ve been making them for years and then one day I had one at a local restaurant that put pesto inside. My mind was blown! My all-time favorite sandwich just got even better! Seriously, it is so good.

Plus this sandwich is super easy to make. It’s basically like making a fancy grilled cheese sandwich and takes 10 minutes or less just like my chicken Caesar wrap and tuna melt sandwich. Can’t beat that! ;)

The bread is perfectly crispy and the flavor combinations are amazing just like my easy Caprese salad. I love how gooey the mozzarella gets too. Mmm…I might have to make this for lunch again today!

Ingredients for Caprese Sandwich

Caprese grilled cheese sandwiches are simple to make and have so much flavor! The combination of mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, and pesto gives a soft, sweet, and crunchy bite with every bite. A light and tasty lunch or dinner that is satisfying in every way!

Find the fullprintable recipewith specific measurements below.

• Sourdough bread: Has a unique flavor that blends well with the layered ingredients.
• Butter: Spread the butter on the two outside pieces of bread to give a crispy outside layer on the bread.
• Basil pesto: Make a homemade basil pesto or have it store-bought.
• Tomato: Sliced tomatoes add a zesty and flavorful combination.
• Mozzarella cheese: Slice about 1/4 inch thick to match the tomatoes. The two together are the perfect combination!

How to Make an Easy Caprese Sandwich

This is a simple caprese sandwich that is light and tasty in every bite. Layer the sandwich and cook the sandwich on a grill pan, griddle, or panini press. An easy sandwich that can be made for a quick lunch!

1. Prepare. Warm a skillet or frying pan over medium heat. Butter both sides of your bread and then grill one side.
2. Cook. Once it has lightly browned, flip the bread over to brown the other side. Turn the heat to low. Then spread the pesto on the grilled side and the cheese on top.
3. Golden brown. Allow the cheese to melt a little, then place tomatoes on top of the cheese followed by the top piece of bread. Turn the heat off if browning too fast and allow the sandwich to sit in the skillet until melted.

Tips for the Best Caprese Sandwich

Make the perfect caprese sandwich with these helpful tips. Choose the right bread, butter is perfect, and make homemade pesto for the best caprese sandwich. This combination layered together makes a great dinner every time!

• Use good quality bread. This really does make a huge difference in taste and crispiness. Look for bread that’s thick and fresh, such as sourdough bread from your local bakery. It makes the sandwich taste like it came straight from the deli!
• Butter the bread. Another key to a super flavorful and crispy sandwich is buttering the bread before frying. Spread the butter evenly on top of each slice of bread, then place that side down onto the pan to fry. It adds amazing flavor and makes the outside super crispy and delicious!
• Homemade pesto. This isn’t a necessity, although making homemade basil pesto really takes this sandwich over the top. If you have lots of basil in your garden, this is the perfect way to use it. You can even make a vegan pesto without the cheese!
• Cheese. Another reason this sandwich is so delicious is all of that melted mozzarella cheese. The key here is to buy a block of mozzarella and cut it into thick slices (about 1/4 inch). Once it melts, it gets super gooey and delicious.

Tasty Additions to your Sandwich

This grilled caprese sandwich is perfect for adding more toppings. Try adding more meat, greens, and even slices of avocados. Take your sandwich to the next level!

• Balsamic. To give it that true caprese taste, add a small drizzle of balsamic glaze over top of the tomatoes. Absolute perfection!
• Meat. This sandwich would also taste delicious with sliced cooked chicken added in.
• Arugula. It’s sturdy in structure with a subtle peppery taste, making it the perfect way to pack more greens into your sandwich.
• Garlic powder. After buttering the bread, add a sprinkle of garlic powder on top for even more flavor. It’s basically like making a sandwich with your favorite garlic bread!
• Avocado. Adding a few slices of fresh avocado is always a good idea!

More Caprese Inspired Recipes

HUNGRY FOR MORE? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all the newest recipes!